Parallels
5:32 pm
Tue July 30, 2013

Anti-Gay Riot In Tblisi Tests Balance Between Church, State

Originally published on Tue July 30, 2013 8:06 pm

While gay rights have been gaining ground in the West, they've been facing a strong backlash in many countries of the former Soviet Union.

Russia recently passed a law that makes it a crime to give information about "non-traditional sexual relationships" to minors.

Gay-rights advocates say the wording of the law is so vague that it can be used to ban gay-pride parades or, in fact, any public discussion of same-sex issues.

Homosexuality was a crime in the former Soviet Union, and it remains so in former Soviet republics such as Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan.

The former Soviet republic of Georgia is contending with the aftermath of an episode of mass violence that took place in May. In Georgia's capital city, Tblisi, a mob of thousands attacked a small group of people who were staging a protest against homophobia.

The leaders of the attack? Georgian Orthodox priests.

The episode raised issues about human rights in a religiously conservative country, as well as questions about the balance of power between church and state.

Priests Among Violent Attackers

The incident began when members of Georgia's lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community and their supporters obtained a permit to hold a vigil on the steps of parliament.

They planned to mark the International Day Against Homophobia on May 17.

When some leaders of the Georgian Orthodox Church heard about it, they urged their congregations to come to a counterdemonstration, which was promoted as a peaceful and family-oriented event.

When the day came, it was anything but peaceful.

Led by Orthodox priests, the crowd overwhelmed the police barrier around the small group of anti-homophobia demonstrators. Video from the clash shows a priest brandishing a stool as a weapon; other priests are heard to curse and yell "Kill them! Kill them!"

Nino Kharchilava was part of a small group of demonstrators that never even made it to the parliament steps. They were surrounded by counterdemonstrators and threatened until police hustled them into a minibus in an effort to get them away from the mob.

Kharchilava is a project assistant for the Women's Initiatives Supporting Group in Tblisi. She says the bus, too, was overwhelmed by attackers, who smashed most of the windows and thrust their hands through the broken glass to get at the demonstrators inside.

"One guy was like, hitting [at] me, and I just tried to communicate and tried to say 'What are you doing?' " she recalls. "And when I saw the blood around, and I couldn't figure out whether this blood is mine, or not, and then I realized it's not my blood, it's their blood."

"You know, they were ready to kill themselves [in order to kill] us," Kharchilava says. "It was really insane."

Church Does Not Punish Participants

The Rev. Mikael Botkovali, a spokesman for the Orthodox Church, brought members of his own congregation to the demonstration.

On a recent day, he sits in the calm baptistery of his church, surrounded by saints painted in the Byzantine style.

Botkovali says the church opposes homosexuality, but it doesn't seek to interfere with what gay people do in private. Where the faithful must speak out, he says, is when LGBT people seek to spread what he calls "homosexual propaganda."

"Religion obliges us to talk to these people and to show them that they're wrong, they're sinners," he says. "Even in the Bible, it's written about these people that, all of them, they will go to hell."

But Botkovali condemns the violence and says the priests who led it were rightly punished under civil and church law.

When pressed, he concedes that the church punishment consists only of suspending the priests from serving for a while and sending them to a monastery outside the city until they confess their errors.

After the violence, Georgia's prime minister, Bidzina Ivanishvili, said that those who promoted the violence would be punished.

A Test For The Rule Of Law

But gay-rights activist Irakli Vacharadze says that so far, the civil punishment hasn't been strong enough to show that Georgia's new government is willing to apply the rule of law to such a popular and powerful institution as the church.

Vacharadze is the executive director of an LGBT organization called Identova, or "Identity," and he was at the May 17 demonstration. He says that key members of Georgia's parliament, including the head of the Committee on Human Rights, have declared themselves subservient to the patriarch of the Orthodox Church.

"What does it mean," Vacharadze asks, "when the chair of the human rights committee says that 'our statement on the human rights violations will not go over what the patriarch has said'? It's a theocracy. It's quite dangerous. We don't want to turn Georgia into next Iran."

Lasha Bakradze, the head of the Georgian Literature Museum in Tblisi, helped organize an online petition against homophobic violence. He says more than 12,000 people signed the petition in its first two days online.

The mass violence on May 17 isn't just about sexual orientation and traditional values, Bakradze says, it's a demonstration of power by extremists who have made their way into the higher levels of the church.

"I think that the church in Georgia has shown to the government how powerful [it is] ... and it's dangerous, and it's against Georgian statehood," he says.

But Archil Kbilashvili, Georgia's chief prosecutor, says the case is not over, and that priests who were involved in the violence still face charges that could require them to serve jail time.

And, he says, no matter what the outcome, the case will serve as a key precedent.

"We cannot remember when our prosecution office introduced charges against some spiritual leaders," Kbilashvili says.

LGBT rights groups say they're still waiting for proof that the government will hold those spiritual leaders to account under the law.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

The former Soviet Republic of Georgia is contending with the aftermath of an episode of mass violence. This past May, in the capital Tbilisi, a mob of thousands attacked a small group of people who were protesting against homophobia. The attack was led by Georgian Orthodox priests. As NPR's Corey Flintoff reports, the incident has raised questions about human rights in Georgia and about the balance of power between church and state.

COREY FLINTOFF, BYLINE: May 17 marks a yearly event known as IDAHO, the International Day Against Homophobia. Members of Georgia's lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community and their supporters obtained a permit to hold a vigil on the steps of parliament. When some leaders of the Georgian Orthodox Church heard about it, they urged their congregation to come to a counter-demonstration, which was promoted as a peaceful and family-oriented event. When the day came, it was anything but peaceful.

(SOUNDBITE OF SCREAMS)

FLINTOFF: Led by Orthodox priests, the crowd overwhelmed the police barrier around a small group of anti-homophobia demonstrators. Video from the clash shows a priest brandishing a stool as a weapon, other priests are heard to curse and yell: Kill them, kill them.

Nino Kharchilava is a project assistant for the Women's Initiative Supporting Group in Tbilisi. She was part of a small group of demonstrators that was hustled into a minibus by police. The bus, too, was overwhelmed by attackers who smashed most of the windows and thrust their hands through the broken glass to get at the demonstrators inside.

NINO KHARCHILAVA: One guy was like hitting on me and I just tried to communicate and tried to say, what are you doing. And when I saw the blood around, and I couldn't figure out whether this blood is mine or not, and then I realized it's not my blood. It's their blood, you know, they were ready to kill themselves for killing us or something. It was really insane.

FLINTOFF: Father Mikael Botkovali is an Orthodox Church spokesman who brought members of his own congregation to the demonstration. He sits in the calm baptistery of his church, surrounded by saints painted in the Byzantine style. Speaking through a translator, Father Botkoveli says the church opposes homosexuality but it doesn't seek to interfere with what gay people do in private. Where the faithful must speak out, he says, is when LGBT people seek to spread what he calls homosexual propaganda.

THE REV. MIKAEL BOTKOVALI: (Through Translator) Religion obliged them to talk to these people and to show them that they're wrong, they're sinners. And he says that even in the Bible it's written that - about these people, that all of them, they will go to Hell.

FLINTOFF: But Father Mikael condemns the violence and says the priests who led it were rightly punished under civil and church law. When pressed, he concedes that the church punishment consists only of suspending the priests from serving for while and sending them to a monastery outside the city until they confess their errors. Some activists say that, so far, the civil punishment hasn't been strong enough to show that Georgia's new government is willing to apply the rule of law to such a popular and powerful institution as the church.

Lasha Bakradze is head of the Georgian Literature Museum in Tbilisi. He helped organize an online petition against homophobic violence. Bakradze says that more than 12,000 signed the petition in its first two days online. He sees the mass violence on May 12th as about more than sexual orientation and traditional values. Bakradze sees the clash as a demonstration of power by extremists who've made their way into the higher levels of the church.

LASHA BAKRADZE: I think that the church in Georgia showed to the government how powerful is the church. And it's dangerous and it is against Georgian statehood.

FLINTOFF: But Archil Kbilashvili, the chief prosecutor of Georgia, says the case is not over and that priests who were involved in the violence still face charges that could require them to serve jail time. And, he says, no matter what the outcome, the case will serve as a key precedent.

ARCHIL KBILASHVILI: We cannot remember when our prosecution office introduced charges against some spiritual leaders. So this is here very important.

FLINTOFF: But LGBT rights groups say they're still waiting for proof that the government will hold those spiritual leaders to account under the law.

Cory Flintoff, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program