Parallels
9:47 am
Mon November 25, 2013

Can Child Marriages Be Stopped?

Originally published on Mon November 25, 2013 6:05 pm

Christina Asima seems tired for a 13-year-old. I meet the shy-mannered girl in the remote farming village of Chitera, in the southern African nation of Malawi. She wears a bright pink zip-up shirt and a blue print cloth wrapped up to her chest. Snuggled in that, hugging her side, is a chubby-cheeked baby boy.

My gut assumption is that the infant must be Christina's little brother. I know 8-month-old Praise is actually her son. Still, it's startling when, as we speak, she shifts him around front to nurse.

"I was 12 years old when I got married to my husband," she explains softly. "My mom had run away, so I was forced to get married to help my other siblings."

Despite decades of international and local efforts to curb child marriage, Christina is hardly alone. Across the developing world, it's estimated that 1 in 3 girls still marries before age 18; 1 in 9 marries before age 15. And the numbers are even worse in Malawi.

"When they see a girl child, in our country, you don't think of anything else but marriage," says Faith Phiri, a Malawian trying to change such attitudes. Five years ago she created the nonprofit Girls Empowerment Network to challenge the complex mix of culture, economics and sexism that drives child marriage.

Pregnancy Is Leading Cause Of Death

Here, as in many places, offering up a daughter for marriage can bring parents a dowry, or pay down a debt. Some see it as a way to protect a girl's virginity. The common thread is that the girl herself has no say.

Many soon become pregnant, which can have devastating consequences. Phiri says many girls' bodies are simply not developed enough to support a baby, or to push it out.

"I've seen a lot of girls dying," she says, "one of whom was my closest friend. She was forced into marriage, got pregnant, and she did not make it."

In fact, pregnancy and childbirth are the leading causes of death worldwide for girls ages 15 to 19.

In Chitera, Phiri guides me down a rutted alley to the concrete courtyard of a mud-brick home. A girl in a denim skirt is leaning over a plastic bucket, washing white cloth diapers.

Arinafe Makwiti, 13, says the diapers are for her 9-month-old daughter. Out of earshot, she blames her parents for her situation.

"They didn't want me to go to school," she says, "but rather to get married."
There was no ceremony. No celebration. Arinafe simply moved in with her new husband's family. She says it was awful.

"My in-laws shouted at me," she says. "I had no peace of mind. I only got one meal a day."

Patriarchy runs deep in Africa. When a girl marries young, experts say, she's often little more than a servant and is vulnerable to domestic violence. Arinafe says her husband was older — she's not sure by how much — and taller.

"The first day, it was like he was big and I felt very small," she says. I ask about her first night with the man, and she looks down to the side as she answers.

"I cried because the pain was very unbearable," she says. "He asked, 'Why are you crying?' I said, 'I'm feeling too much pain,' but he continued. Unfortunately, I got pregnant."

She and her husband have since divorced. Arinafe's mother, Rose, is not happy about the split.

"My daughter was running around too much," she tells me. "I thought marriage would settle her down." Arinafe says she wants to go back to school, but when I ask her mother about that possibility, her face hardens.

"It's more difficult than ever to come up with the school fees," she says. "My daughter used to sell oranges and mangoes. Now, she has to carry a baby on her back."

Helping Girls Re-Imagine Their Future

"All along, the girls have been so silent," says activist Faith Phiri. "It was the communities who have been thinking for the girls. They think that, 'Marriage is good for you girls.' But we're saying, 'Girls, what do you think?' "

To that end, the Girls Empowerment Network creates girls clubs, like the one I visit in another dusty farming village an hour away, Sandrack.

Two-dozen girls are squeezed into a tiny community hall, dancing in a circle, taking turns singing in the center. Girls Empowerment organizer Trinitas Mhango greets them with a "Whoo-hoo!" and they shout back with big smiles.

Mhango has the girls tell the story of their young lives, complete with the daunting challenges they've faced so far. Then she asks them to dream, and to plan. "Ruthie," she asks one 17-year-old, "in five years, what do you want to be?"

"An accountant," Ruthie ventures, to which Mhango whoops again, and rallies the group in a round of applause.

It may seem hokey; saying you want to be an accountant doesn't get you there. But in fact, the few studies done on child marriage prevention say building this kind of social network is key. With it comes skills for public speaking, negotiating and standing up for oneself, even in front of the whole village.

The next day, it's showtime. The girls club and other young people in Sandrack are putting on their own play. A shady patch of dirt under some trees has been transformed into a stage. Village leaders settle into a front-row wood bench. Dozens more form a large circle; they've come by bike and foot from miles around to see this.

Act One: A charming man comes to court a young girl. Her parents are thrilled when he offers a backpack bursting with money. The knot is tied; the girl drops out of school.

But in Act Two, when she goes to sell her new husband's vegetables at market, her math skills fall short. The audience hoots as she counts on fingers and toes. The young bride sells for too little. The husband is not pleased.

No subtlety there. Yet getting the message across can be tough.

Changing Laws, One Village At A Time

In both villages I visit, pretty much every adult I ask about the Girls Empowerment Network says the same thing.

"At first, we were thinking it's a matter of wasting our time," says Emanuel Mandam, a "headman" in Chitera. He didn't like the idea of ending child marriage at all, because "early marriage to us was a weapon for reducing poverty."

A girl's husband may bring a family much-needed money, he says, either through a dowry or by simply helping out with expenses. At the least, marrying off a girl means one less mouth to feed. But after the village girls presented their grievances, Mandam says, he came around.

"Education can make somebody prosper," he says, "maybe for my daughter to do better in the future."

Mandam's daughter is 12, and he says he has already begun planning the extra work he must do to continue paying her school fees.

Malawi law permits marriage at 15 with parental consent and merely "discourages" it at younger ages. But last summer Chitera passed its own legal age of marriage — 21 — with the ambitious goal that every girl attend college.

To minimize distractions, there's a new 6 p.m. curfew for young people. And there's been a change at the local movie house, a thatched hut with an old TV and videotape machine. The day I visit, a horror flick is playing at high volume, completely innappropriate for the kids lining wooden benches watching. But they used to show porn here; that's no longer allowed.

By far the biggest change: a steep penalty if parents marry off a daughter before age 21.

"They have to give five goats to the chief," says another local official, Roben Ndrama, "and eight chickens to the village headmen."

In a more humiliating measure, some parents have been made to scrub clean the local health center. Ndrama laughs when I ask if parents get mad about that.

"It's worked!" he says. "This year there've been no early marriages."

More than 20 communities have passed similar rules. Still, in a country the size of Pennsylvania, Faith Phiri faces heavy pushback as she tries to change centuries of thinking. But she hopes new attitudes are sinking in, and spreading, village by village, girl by girl.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Audie Cornish.

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

And I'm Melissa Block.

In the U.S., we talk a lot about people getting married later and later in life. But in vast parts of the world, parents often marry off young girls who are barely out of puberty. One-in-three girls in the developing world are married before she's age 18, one-in-nine before she's 15. Western nations and aid groups have been stepping up pressure, along with local activists, all struggling to change age old practices.

NPR's Jennifer Ludden reports from the southern African nation of Malawi.

JENNIFER LUDDEN, BYLINE: I head out of the sleepy city of Blantyre to the countryside. It's a bone-jarring journey on deeply rutted dirt roads. We pass a crowded, hillside cluster of wood shacks. Outdoor markets sell used electronics and secondhand shoes. Then the land opens up to flat brown fields, waiting to be planted with maize. After an hour, we pull into a loose collection of mud brick homes, with roofs of thatch or corrugated metal.

(SOUNDBITE OF A VEHICLE)

LUDDEN: And here an area called Chitera, I meet a shy-mannered girl with close cropped hair.

CHRISTINA ASIMA: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: I'm 13, says Christina Asima. She wears a bright pink zip-up shirt and a blue print cloth wrapped up to her chest. Snuggled in that, hugging her side, is a chubby cheeked baby boy.

(SOUNDBITE OF A CRYING BABY)

LUDDEN: How old?

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: (Foreign language spoken)

ASIMA: (Through translator) Eight months.

LUDDEN: What's his name?

ASIMA: Praise.

LUDDEN: Praise, hi.

My gut reaction is that Praise must be Christina's little brother. I know he's not. Still, it's startling when, as we speak, Christina shifts him around front to nurse.

ASIMA: (Through translator) I was 12 years old when I got married to my husband. Just because my mom run away from me, so I was forced to get married to help my other siblings.

FAITH PHIRI: When they see a girl child in our country, you don't think of anything else but marriage.

LUDDEN: That's Faith Phiri, a Malawian activist trying to change such attitudes. Five years ago, she created a nonprofit, the Girls Empowerment Network.

PHIRI: OK...

LUDDEN: Here in Chitera, Phiri checks in with a circle of village leaders. She says child marriage is driven by a complex mix of culture, economics and sexism. Offering up a daughter can bring parents a dowry or pay down a debt. Some see it as a way to protect a girl's virginity. The common thread: The girl herself has no say. Even more devastating?

PHIRI: Getting pregnant.

LUDDEN: Phiri says many girls' bodies are simply not developed enough to support a baby or push it out.

PHIRI: I've seen a lot of girls dying. One of whom was my closest friend. She was forced into marriage, got pregnant, and she didn't make it.

LUDDEN: In fact, pregnancy and childbirth are the leading causes of death worldwide for girls age 15 to 19.

Down a dusty alley, past a make-shift movie theatre, Phiri leads me to another family in Chitera. In a courtyard, over a plastic bucket, a girl in a denim skirt scrubs white cloth diapers.

(SOUNDBITE OF SPLASHING WATER)

LUDDEN: She is also 13.

And how did you spell your name?

ARINAFE MAKWITI: A-R-I-N-A-F-E.

LUDDEN: Arinafe Makwiti says the diapers are for her nine-month-old daughter. Out of earshot, she blames her parents for her situation.

MAKWITI: (Through translator) They didn't want me to go to school, but rather to get married.

LUDDEN: There was no ceremony. No celebration. Arinafe simply moved in with her new husband's family. She says it was awful.

When a girl marries young, experts say she's often little more than a servant, vulnerable to domestic violence. Arinafe's husband was older - she's not sure how much - and taller.

MAKWITI: (Foreign language spoken)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: The first day, it was like he was big and she looked herself as very small and that's how she felt.

LUDDEN: So what was your first night with this person like, with your husband?

MAKWITI: (Through translator) I cried because the pain was very unbearable.

(Foreign language spoken)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: The husband asked her: Why are you crying. So she said I'm feeling too much pain. But he continued.

LUDDEN: Unfortunately, Arinafe says, I got pregnant. She and her husband have since divorced.

Arinafe's mother, Rose, is not happy about the split. We speak as an action movie blares next door.

ROSE MAKWITI: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: My daughter was running around too much, she says. I thought marriage would settle her down. What about school? Arinafe says she wants to go back. Makwiti's face hardens.

MAKWITI: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: It's more difficult than ever to come up with the school fees, she says. My daughter used to sell oranges and mangos. Now she has to carry a baby on her back.

(SOUNDBITE OF SINGING)

LUDDEN: An hour away, another farming village, Sandrack. Two dozen girls are squeezed into a tiny community hall. They dance in a circle, taking turns in the center.

(SOUNDBITE OF SINGING AND CLAPPING)

LUDDEN: This is a key part of the Girls Empowerment Network. Faith Phiri says her strategy to stop child marriage starts with the girls themselves.

PHIRI: All along, the girls have been so silent. It was the communities who have been thinking for the girls. They think that marriage is good for you, girls. But our approach we're saying: Girls, what do you think?

TRINITAS MHANGO: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: Phiri's colleague, Trinitas Mhango, leads this girls' club. She asks a 17-year-old named Ruth to dream and plan: In five years, what do you want to be.

RUTH: Accountant.

MHANGO: Accountant, OK. (Foreign language spoken) Ruth wants to be an accountant. (Foreign language spoken) Woo-hoo.

(SOUNDBITE OF CHEERING)

LUDDEN: It may seem hokey. Saying you want to be an accountant doesn't get you there. But, in fact, the few studies done on child marriage prevention say building this kind of social network is key. With it comes skills for public speaking, negotiating, standing up for oneself even in front of the whole village.

(SOUNDBITE OF DRUMMING)

LUDDEN: The next day, it's show time. The girls club and other young people in Sandrack are putting on their own play. This shady patch of dirt under some glycedia trees is the stage. Village leaders settle into a front row wood bench. Dozens more have come by bike and foot from miles around to see this.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #3: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: Act 1: A charming man comes to court a young girl. Her parents are thrilled when he offers a backpack bursting with money.

(SOUNDBITE OF CHEERING)

LUDDEN: The knot is tied. The girl drops out of school. But when she goes to sell her new husband's vegetables at market...

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #4: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: Her math skills fall short. The audience hoots as she sells for too little. The husband is not happy.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken)

(LAUGHTER)

LUDDEN: The message seems clear. But getting it across can be tough.

EMANUEL MANDAM: (Through translator) At first, we were thinking it's a matter of wasting our time.

LUDDEN: Emanuel Mandam is a so-called headman in Chitera, where we met the young mothers. He didn't like the idea of ending child marriage at all.

MANDAM: (Through translator) Marriage - early marriage to us, it was a weapon for reducing poverty in our community.

LUDDEN: A weapon for reducing poverty, he says, because the girl's husband may bring the family money. At the least, hers is one less mouth to feed. But after the village girls presented their grievances, Mandam says he came around.

MANDAM: (Through translator) Education can make somebody to prosper, maybe for my daughter to do better in the future.

LUDDEN: Under Malawi law, a girl can marry at just about any age with parental consent. But last summer, fellow headman Roben Ndrama says Chitera passed its own legal age of marriage.

ROBEN NDRAMA: It's 21 years, is it?

LUDDEN: Yes, it's 21. He says all the village girls should go to college - pretty ambitious. To minimize distractions, there's a new 6 p.m. curfew for young people. And there's been a change back at that local movie house, a thatched hut with an old TV and videotape machine.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE)

LUDDEN: OK, this horror flick is completely inappropriate for the kids lining wooden benches to see it. But they used to show porn.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE)

LUDDEN: By far the biggest change: A steep penalty if parents marry off a daughter before age 21.

NDRAMA: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: Ndrama says, they have to give five goats to the chief and eight chickens to the village headmen. In a more humiliating measure, some parents have been made to scrub clean the local health center. Seriously.

NDRAMA: (Foreign language spoken) true.

LUDDEN: Now, do they accept this or they must get awfully mad at you?

NDRAMA: (Foreign language spoken)

LUDDEN: It's worked, he says. This year there have been no early marriages. Still, this is one village in a country the size of Pennsylvania. Faith Phiri faces heavy pushback as she tries to change centuries of thinking. But she hopes new attitudes are sinking in, and spreading, village by village, girl by girl. Jennifer Ludden, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program