Most Active Stories
- Unification Of Ypsilanti And Willow Run School Districts Fast Approaching
- Roundabout Construction Near Costco Will Soon Be Underway
- Controversial 413 East Huron Development Project wins Ann Arbor City Council Approval
- Local cyclists organize 'Ride of Silence' in Ann Arbor, Ypsilani
- Ann Arbor In Concert To Hold Inaugural Performance
Mon September 17, 2012
China Ratchets Up The Rhetoric In Island Spat With Japan
Originally published on Tue September 18, 2012 9:52 am
China's state-run media is warning that Japan could endure another "lost decade" of economic stagnation should Beijing resort to trade retaliation over Japan's purchase of disputed islands.
The warning comes amid a surge of anti-Japanese nationalism across China that sparked huge and sometimes violent protests over the weekend. As the economic cost of the protests begins to escalate, it's becoming clearer exactly who might be behind them.
Today in Beijing, small groups of protesters marched in front of the Japanese Embassy, its walls still yolk-stained after being pelted with eggs and water bottles over the weekend. The marchers were protesting against Japan's purchase last week of disputed islands known as Diaoyu in China and Senkaku in Japan. Almost all the demonstrators say they came out spontaneously to protest. But an onlooker who gave his name as Mr. Luo lets slip that he'd like to march, but today isn't his day to do so.
"I haven't been organized to demonstrate," the man says. "I'm having the day off. The government controls and organizes the demonstrations. You can't just go if you like. At the very least, there's organization among the universities. There are half a million college students in Beijing. If they all came here at once, it'd be unimaginable."
Over the weekend, the streets were lined by young men in matching black T-shirts marked Chaoyang Security. Today, hundreds of people all wearing red armbands marked "public security volunteers" sat perched on low stools about a foot apart on the sidewalks. Phalanxes of riot police armed with shields stood guard before embassy and uniformed policemen, paramilitary police and a host of other security personnel seemed to materialize from nowhere.
All of this points to just how many bodies the Chinese state can mobilize if officials wish to do so.
That much became clear during an encounter with a man draped in a Chinese flag who was watching the protest. "I feel extremely proud to be able to play a tiny role in defending my motherland's sovereignty," he says, drawing the flag around his shoulders.
He refused to give his name, and when he asked me to interview someone else, I pointed out that everyone else around us is a policeman.
"How do you know I'm not a policeman?" he asks.
"I don't," I reply. "Are you a policeman?"
"Don't ask me that," he says. When I pressed him, he told me to stop making such a fuss about whether he's a policeman. Such an encounter would seem to chime with rumors flying around Beijing that the security forces are sometimes involved in these demonstrations.
Just down the road from the embassy is a street full of Japanese and Korean restaurants.
Many of them have draped Chinese flags as well as huge red banners proclaiming, "The Diaoyu islands are China's" across their facades, sometimes obscuring the name of the restaurant. In this volatile atmosphere, Japanese businesses can find themselves the targets of mob rage, and these restaurants are doing what they can to pre-empt that.
In the southern city of Zhuhai, protestors smashed Japanese shop and car windows over the weekend. Eleven protestors have been detained for violence in Guangzhou.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei has called on demonstrators to behave in a "rational and legal" fashion. At the same time, he sent mixed messages, saying, "The gravely destructive consequences of Japan's illegal purchase of the Diaoyu islands are steadily emerging, and the responsibility for this should be born by Japan."
Japanese businesses are taking fright. Three Canon factories have temporarily been shut, and Panasonic is taking similar steps. Many Chinese tourists are canceling flights to Japan. The China Daily newspaper ran an opinion piece suggesting economic sanctions against Japan.
Whipping up anti-Japanese sentiment could be useful for China's leaders, according to Hu Xingdou, a political analyst at Beijing Institute of Technology.
"There are very intense problems inside China: The gap between rich and poor is very big, there are serious corruption problems, and the contradictions between the people and the government are very intense," Hu says. "Under such circumstances, it could be natural to get people to unite against other countries to strengthen internal unity."
But he warns it could also be dangerous: "I think it's a double-edged sword. Anti-Japanese sentiment could get out of control. In the past, blind anti-foreign patriotism hindered China's progress. Patriotism is often a shelter for political hooligans."
One big test comes tomorrow, the anniversary of the 1931 Mukden Incident that led to Japan's invasion of China. This coincides with a visit to Beijing by U.S. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, who has expressed concern about the escalation of tensions.
But having unleashed the demons of anti-Japanese nationalism, China may find itself backed into a corner by its own citizens, demanding a harder line on Japan, whatever the cost.
Louisa Lim is NPR's Beijing correspondent.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
China is threatening Japan with trade retaliation, this after a weekend of anti-Japanese protests across China over Japan's purchase of disputed islands in the East China Sea. The economic costs of these protests is beginning to escalate. And NPR's Louisa Lim has been asking exactly who's behind them.
UNIDENTIFIED PEOPLE: (Singing in foreign language)
LOUISA LIM, BYLINE: Small groups of protestors sing China's national anthem this morning, as they march in front of the Japanese embassy in Beijing. Its walls are still stained after being pelted with eggs. The marchers are protesting against Japan's purchase last week of disputed islands known as Diaoyu in China and Senkaku in Japan. Here I meet a Mr. Luo. He'd like to protest, he says, but today isn't his day to do so.
MR. LUO: (Through translator) I haven't been organized to demonstrate. I'm having the day off. The government controls and organizes the demonstrations. You can't just go if you like. At the very least, there's organization among the universities. There are half a million students in Beijing. If they all came here at once, it would be unimaginable.
LIM: There's an extraordinary level of organization here in front of the Japanese embassy. The sidewalks are lined with people. They're all wearing red armbands saying public security volunteers. And these are, of course, on top of the policemen and paramilitary troops and anti-riot police that we see. But it's really a sign of just how many bodies the Chinese state can mobilize, if they wish to do so.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken)
LIM: That becomes clear when I interview this man who won't give his name. He's draped in a Chinese flag and he says he's proud to defend the sovereignty of the motherland. When he tells me to interview someone else, I point out that everyone else around us are policemen.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken)
LIM: How do you know I'm not a policeman, he asks me. I don't, I reply. Are you a policeman?
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: (Foreign language spoken)
LIM: Don't ask me that, he says. When I press him, he tells me to stop making such a fuss about whether or not he's a policeman. After this conversation, my guess is that there are police in plainclothes among the protestors.
There's a street of Korean and Japanese restaurants. All of them have hung up huge red banners outside the restaurants saying the Diaoyu islands are China's. In this very volatile atmosphere, any business - particularly a Japanese business - can find itself targeted, and these restaurants are trying to avoid that.
(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)
LIM: In the southern city of Zhuhai, protestors smashed Japanese shop and car windows. Japanese businesses are now taking fright. Three Canon factories have temporarily shut. Chinese tourists are cancelling flights to Japan. But whipping up anti-Japanese sentiment could end up harming China, according to Hu Xingdou, a political analyst at Beijing Institute of Technology.
HU XINGDOU: (Through translator) I think it's a double edged sword. Anti-Japanese sentiment could get out of control. In the past, blind anti-foreign patriotism hindered China's progress. Patriotism is often a shelter for political hooligans.
LIM: One big test comes tomorrow, the anniversary of Japan's invasion of China in 1931. This coincides with a visit to Beijing by Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, who's expressed concern about the escalation of tensions. But having unleashed the demons of anti-Japanese nationalism, China may find itself backed into a corner by its own citizens demanding a harder line on Japan, whatever the cost.
Louisa Lim, NPR News, Beijing. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.